Masterpiece Cakeshop Baker Loses Appeal over Gender-Transition Cake
Masterpiece Cakeshop Baker Loses Appeal over Gender-Transition Cake

Share
January 26, 2023 9:03 PMListen to article
Christian baker Jack Phillips on Thursday lost his appeal in a case that stemmed from his refusal to make a cake for an individual’s gender transition.
TOP STORIES
Trump Has Completely Lost His Grip on Reality
CHARLES C. W. COOKE
Video-Game Company Caves to Trans Activist’s Online Pressure Campaign, Fires Targeted Employee
CAROLINE DOWNEY
What Could Explain Why Supreme Court Justices Are ‘Somehow’ Following the Law?
DAN MCLAUGHLIN
A Colorado Court of Appeals three-judge panel, all appointed by Democratic governors, upheld an earlier court decision requiring Phillips to bake the cake. Attorneys from Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF) representing Phillips said Thursday they plan to appeal the ruling.
Phillips won a case before the U.S. Supreme Court in 2018 over his refusal to make a custom wedding cake for a same-sex couple. Autumn Scardina tried to order a cake from Masterpiece Cakeshop that was blue on the outside and pink on the inside in honor of Scardina’s gender transition, on the same day in 2017 that the Supreme Court announced it would hear Phillips’s appeal in the wedding-cake case.
Scardina said during a March 2021 trial that the attempt to order the cake was a test to see whether Phillips would make good on his assertion that he would sell any other type of product but opposed making a gay couple’s wedding cake because, as a Christian, he was opposed to the religious ceremony involved, according to CBS Denver.
https://imasdk.googleapis.com/js/core/bridge3.553.0_en.html#goog_1784205671Top Stories
READ MOREMy Holiday from Twitter
Scardina’s lawyer, Paula Greisen, claimed the call was not a “setup” but rather “more of calling someone’s bluff.”
Phillips’s lawyer, Sean Gates, said the baker could not create the cake because he did not agree with the message it would send: that gender transition is something to be celebrated.
He argued that it was not discrimination against Scardina and later added that Phillips had also declined to make cakes with other messages he disagreed with, such as Halloween images.
More onFREE SPEECH
Ultra-Woke Illinois Mandates Are Top Threat to U.S. Education
Top EU Bureaucrat Predicts Hate-Speech Laws Coming to U.S.
Why I Keep Getting Mistaken for a Conservative
The court found “that the act of baking a pink cake with blue frosting does not constitute protected speech under the First Amendment.”
“Additionally, the division concludes that CADA’s [Colorado Anti-Discrimination Act] prohibition against discrimination based on a person’s transgender status does not violate a proprietor’s right to freely exercise or express their religion,” the court wrote.
The court ruled Phillips’s right to an accommodation based on his religious beliefs would not override Scardina’s “protected status” because the cake request did not have an “inherent meaning or expressed message.”
ADF senior counsel Jake Warner, who is representing Phillips in the case, responded to the ruling in a statement: “No one should be forced to express a message that violates their core beliefs.”
“Over a decade ago, Colorado officials began targeting Jack, misusing state law to force him to say things he does not believe,” Warner added. “Then an activist attorney continued that crusade. This cruelty must stop. One need not agree with Jack’s views to agree that all Americans should be free to say what they believe, even if the government disagrees with those beliefs.”
John McHugh, an attorney for Scardina, called the ruling was a “victory” for Scardina and the “greater LGBTQ community” in a statement to the Daily Caller.
“The court held that Masterpiece Cakeshop broke the law when it refused to sell a birthday cake to Ms. Scardina because she is a transgender woman,” McHugh told the outlet. “In doing so, the court rejected the defendants’ free speech argument because, as defendants admitted at trial, a pink cake with blue frosting does not have any inherent meaning and the act of selling a cake is not speech. Similarly, the Court held, consistent with U.S. Supreme Court precedent, that Mr. Phillips’ religious beliefs do not exempt him from anti-discrimination laws.”
Send a tip to the news team at NR.
NEXT NEWS ARTICLEDeSantis Says RNC Needs ‘New Blood’ after ‘Three Substandard Election Cycles’

107COMMENTS
AROUND THE WEB


Arizona Will Cover the Full Cost to Install Solar with Battery if You Live in {C
SMART SOLAR INSTALL

Sneaky Way Phoenix Homeowners Are Getting Their Roof Replaced With This Program
SMART CONSUMER UPDATE

Order Your Own Trump TRB Diamond Bucks Today (Get It Now)
TRB CHECK™
![Struggling with Belly Fat? Try This at Home [It's Genius]](https://images.revcontent.com/revcontent/image/fetch/f_jpg,q_50,h_225,w_300,c_fill,g_face:auto/pg_1/https://media.revcontent.com/content/images/63c04d5508c336-18166536.png)
Struggling with Belly Fat? Try This at Home [It’s Genius]
EASY HEALTH TIPS

Doctors Stunned; Do This Before Bed, Melt Your Belly Fat Like Crazy!
LIVER HEALTH

Need Dental Implants but Have No Money? Get Dental Implants Done in Turkey
DENTAL IMPLANTS IN TURKEY