Headlines

Federal judge slams Jack Smith, blocks release of report on Trump documents case

Share with:


Loading

Federal judge slams Jack Smith, blocks release of report on Trump documents case

By 

Josh Christenson

Published Jan. 21, 2025, 10:38 a.m. ET397 Comments

0 of 1 minute, 12 secondsVolume 0%

A federal judge slammed special counsel Jack Smith on Tuesday and accused his office of seeking to deny two former co-defendants of President Trump a fair trial by releasing a final report on the moribund classified documents case against the commander-in-chief.

In a scathing 14-page order, South Florida US District Judge Aileen Cannon took Smith to task for seeking to disclose details of his lengthy probe to members of Congress — before either defendant heads to trial.

“Never before has the Department of Justice, prior to the conclusion of criminal proceedings against a defendant — and absent a litigation-specific reason as appropriate in the case itself— sought to disclose outside the Department a report prepared by a Special Counsel containing substantive and voluminous case information. Until now,” Cannon wrote.

President Trump signs executive orders in the Oval Office on January 20, 2025.Getty Images

“Meanwhile, on the other side of the balance, there are two individuals in this action, each with constitutional rights to a fair trial, who remain subject to a live criminal appeal of this Court’s Order Dismissing the Superseding Indictment,” she said, referring to Trump co-defendants Walt Nauta and Carlos De Oliveira.

Smith, who resigned from the Justice Department on Jan. 10, had already transmitted to then-Attorney General Merrick Garland a copy of the first volume of his report, which dealt with alleged illegal interference by the 45th and 47th president in the 2020 election.

Garland released that report to the public on Jan. 14, just six days before Trump returned to the White House.

Explore More

Trump announces pardon for Silk Road founder Ross Ulbricht, vacating life sentence

Barack Obama asked George W. Bush how they could "stop what's happening" during President Trump's inauguration on Monday, according to a deaf lip-reader.

Deaf lip reader reveals what Barack Obama said to George W. Bush at Trump inauguration

Elon Musk caused outrage on social media after he placed his right hand over his heart and then extended his arm into the air as he thanked Trump's supporters on Monday ahead of the Inauguration Day parade.

Elon Musk rips those who accused him of giving Nazi salute: ‘Need better dirty tricks’

In it, the special counsel claimed that “but for Mr. Trump’s election and imminent return to the presidency, the office assessed that the admissible evidence was sufficient to obtain and sustain a conviction at trial.”

Smith had asked to share a copy of the report’s second volume with the top Republican and Democrat on the House and Senate Judiciary Committees, saying it could be used for “possible legislative reforms regarding the use of special counsels”

Lawyers for Nauta and De Oliveira objected to that move as well as any public release, claiming it could harm Trump’s transition efforts, violate DOJ policy on releasing information during an ongoing criminal proceeding and deny their clients a right to a fair trial.

Special counsel Jack Smith speaks to members of the media at the US Department of Justice building in Washington, DC, on August 1, 2023.
Special counsel Jack Smith speaks to members of the media at the US Department of Justice building in Washington, DC, on August 1, 2023.AFP via Getty Images

In her ruling, Cannon sided with the defense, pointing out that the report had not been subpoenaed by any congressional committee or talked about as the foundation of future legislation.

“There is no ‘historical practice’ of providing Special Counsel reports to Congress, even on a limited basis, pending conclusion of criminal proceedings,” she noted. “In fact, there is not one instance of this happening until now.”

Cannon threw out th

Share with:


Verified by MonsterInsights